Evaluating Children’s Books

Hands down…teaching about literacy and all that it entails is one of my most favorite concepts to teach in child development! Maybe it’s my love of reading, my love of great children’s books or my love of seeing children engaged in reading great children’s books! Either way, it’s an engaging and fun unit to teach and share with my students. In the past I’ve shared many posts about literacy and reading to children, but I have never shared my lesson on evaluating children’s books. Read on to learn more about this lesson!


  • Utilizing the SKETCHNOTES technique that I featured in a previous post, I have students begin by creating a notes page titled, “Top Ten Characteristics of a Good Children’s Book”. I go over the SKETCHNOTES concept and show them some samples of other classes work so they get an idea of what this can look like. I stress that I’m not grading on artistic ability. Notes, however, should be neat, reflect personal style and follow the criteria on the guide sheet! Once I’ve gone over the basic info, I provide students links to articles that they must pull their notes from. They must utilize all resources, but include the ten they think are most important. See guide sheet below for specific criteria along with some awesome examples. The articles I use are as follows: Four Characteristics of a Good Children’s Book, What Makes a Good Children’s Book? and Nine Factors that Make a Children’s Book Successful.




  • Since I have the I Am Your Child Series, I do show my students the “Ready to Learn” DVD with Jamie Lee Curtis and LeVar Burton.
  • Students then utilize their SKETCHNOTES as they read and evaluate 3 different children’s books. I set up a whole table full of children’s books. Students choose 3 books that vary in author and theme to evaluate.
  • Students add their criteria to the top portion of the grid on their evaluation paper along with the book titles and author’s names.
  • Then, students read through each book and mark the characteristics present in each book. This part of the assignment is fun to listen to class comments/conversations as many reminisce about where and when they read them as youngsters! From there, they must answer specific questions about each book. They must provide brief summaries, the age-range they feel the book is recommended for, how they can involve the child, suggest an activity that not only extends the book, but also incorporates the PIES and finally list themes within the book.
  • To help students determine the age-range the books are recommended for, I provide them with a guide sheet from our local library that gives some characteristics for each age level.
  • Finally, after students have read/evaluated three books, they must choose one to respond to in the writing prompt. After they write their response, we do a peer review/annotated edit. Students then have the opportunity to make corrections for a better grade. This helps promote/reinforce their writing skills for the state test. If you don’t have to include these core concepts in your lessons, then simply ignore this step.


Similar Lessons

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

2 comments for “Evaluating Children’s Books

  1. Kris
    January 21, 2021 at 8:19 pm

    Kim, I appreciate your resources so much! I also love picture books and want to do this. I have virtual students too….do you think I could still do this or similar with them? Maybe they have picture books at home? Or do you think there's an online source they could read them? Thank you again.

    • K.Graybill
      January 22, 2021 at 6:50 am

      Thank you! Great question! This lesson adapts itself nicely to virtual because most books have a YouTube version! Each page is shown as the reader shares the story so your students can evaluate it as though they were actually reading the book! You may want to create a list for them to choose from or have them share the link of the “book” they are evaluating! Good luck!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.